Skip to content
Menu
My Search for the Past
  • About Me
  • Family in Sweden
  • Links to 52 Ancestors Blogs
  • Kortgardner Photo Collection
  • Tree View for Ancestors of C. Hartley
  • Family Tree for Biermann-Hartley
  • Person Index
  • Privacy Policy
My Search for the Past

Charles Solger – Did He Leave One Family to Start Another? – 52 Ancestors #19

Posted on May 18, 2014October 30, 2025 by Cheryl Biermann Hartley

Entry #19

I am a week behind with my post. I have just returned from vacation in Costa Rica. Pura vida!

My great-grandmother, Julia Magdalena Stephan, was married before she wed my great-grandfather, Gottlob Maier. It is her first husband, Charles P. Solger, who is the subject of my week 19 post. Julia (sometimes Lena and sometimes Maggie) can be found living in a large boardinghouse on Sycamore Street in Cincinnati in the 1880 census. She was working somewhere as a servant. Partway up the page is “Chrest” Solger, a cigar packer from Maryland (hard to read). Is “Chrest” really Charles, or is he a relation of Charles? His marital status is designated as married and he is 35 years old, meaning he was born in about 1845. At any rate, Julia Stephan married Charles Solger on 9 November 1880. They had two sons together, Charles (born 7 August 1881) and Philip (born 4 May 1884). Charles died of Bright’s disease (chronic nephritis) on 29 December 1889. His burial record says that he was 51 years 11 months old at the time of his death; so if correct, he was born closer to February 1838 and nearly 17 years older than Julia.

To this point, Charles Solger did not seem particularly interesting until I happened across the equivalent of a personal ad in the Cincinnati Commercial Tribune from 3 May 1884.  It read:

Girl Searching for Her Father – To the Editor of the Commercial Gazette Indianapolis, IND., May 2 — Will you please insert the following as a reading item and oblige? Miss Lucille Solger, daughter of Charles Solger, would like to hear of her father’s whereabouts. Mr. Solger is a cigar packer, and came to Cincinnati about four years since from Chicago. If this item reaches his eye, or anyone knowing his whereabouts, they will greatly oblige his youthful daughter by letting her know. Miss Lucille Solger 32 S. Mississippi Street, Indianapolis.

  Charles Solger Personal Ad

I searched for Lucille and found her in the 1880 census as Luci Solger. Carl Solger, her father is 47, from Bremen, and a cigar packer; her mother is Eliza. It is not a stretch to imagine that a wife whose husband recently disappeared might say that her husband was living in the household. Carl Solger apparently had 6 children. There are listings for Carl Solger in the Chicago city directories as a cigar packer from 1877-1880.  In 1881, the listing says “laborer” and by 1882 there is no listing for him at all.

Solger, Carl 1880 Chicago census

Hmm…I have Charles Solger as a cigar packer in the Cincinnati city directories for most years beginning in 1880 and running through 1888. In 1888, Lena (Julia) is listed as selling candies, and in 1889, Charles is listed as a confectioner. Charles, of course, passed away at the end of 1889. In 1890, both Lena and Eliza Solger are listed as widow of Charles in the Cincinnati city directory. (Reinhold is the son of Carl by Eliza)

1890 Cincinnati Directory - Solger

In 1891 both women are listed by their names with no mention of Charles and in 1892 neither are listed. By this time Julia/Lena had remarried. It also appears that Eliza filed for a Civil War pension. I have more research to do on Carl/Charles Solger. He appears to have lived in New York and possibly Michigan as well. One more important note is that there was never a name like Christ, Chrest, or Christian Solger in the Cincinnati directories.

I have pretty much convinced myself that Carl and Charles are the same person. Readers, what do you think?

7 thoughts on “Charles Solger – Did He Leave One Family to Start Another? – 52 Ancestors #19”

  1. Pingback: 52 Ancestors Challenge: Week 20 Recap | No Story Too Small
    1. Theodor Hoerl says:
      October 13, 2025 at 4:04 pm

      My great-grandfather, Charles Solger, was born in Chicago about 1870, held in Lake Michigan by his mother during the Chicago Fire. He married Mary Kraus who had emigrated from East Prussia as a baby. They had 2 children, my grandmother Dorothy Solger Mittendorf( born 1896) and Reinhold Charles Solger (b. 1903, I think). He was undoubtedly a rake who occasionally disappeared for extended periods. The reason for my response is the repetition of Reinhold in the family.

      Reply
  2. Susan says:
    June 26, 2014 at 3:01 pm

    Cheryl, my great uncle’s name Is Charles Solger, who was married to Lillian Lind. Charles is the son of Karl Solger who was married to Julia Stephan. I saw an article about Karl or Charles writtten by you.

    I would like to know more!

    Susan Crossland

    Reply
  3. Cheryl Biermann Hartley says:
    June 26, 2014 at 11:29 pm

    Susan, I have sent you a private message on Facebook.

    Reply
  4. Cynthia Gordon (Solger) says:
    February 27, 2024 at 12:25 pm

    My grandfather had a father and a brother named Charles Solger. The later Charles, per my grandmother, was a nare do well who sowed his seeds all over the country. So perhaps the apple did not fall far from the tree. My grandfather did not speak about his dad, but my grandmother did not have anything good to say about his family. Otto’s father was an alcoholic and that trait paralyzes my family until today. They did mention that they emigrated to the US from somewhere near the Polish German border. My grandfathers father Charles was the first generation to live in America

    Are you related to the German writter who influenced Lincoln during the civil war? Relatively speaking there are not many Solgers in this country so I can not help but think that somewhere in the distant past we are all related. Especially knowing that Charles, and Reinhold seem the most used names in three generations.

    Reply
    1. Theodor Hoerl says:
      October 13, 2025 at 4:15 pm

      I suspect that the neer-do-well Charles Solger was my great grandfather born about 1870 in Chicago where he lived most of his life, with a number of side trips for who knows what. He was a tool and die man for Tesla when he was in Chicago. He was married to Mary Kraus (born October 4 1871 in East Prussia, , died in the Chicago TB Sanitarium in the 1930s). They had 2 Children, Dorothy Solger Mittendorf, my grandmother (born 1896) and Reinhold (born 1903, I think) Are you related to Lil Solger? She was the apparent source of many negative thoughts about Charles and Reinhold.

      Reply
    2. Theodor Hoerl says:
      February 23, 2026 at 1:26 pm

      Was your Grandmother named Lill?

      Reply

Leave a Reply to Theodor Hoerl Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comment Policy

Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved.

Thoughtful discussion is welcome. This site is grounded in documented genealogical research, and comments that contain misinformation or unsupported claims will not be approved.

Recent Posts

  • Unraveling the Disappearance of Francis Stephan: How DNA Rewrote a Family Legend
  • From Brick Walls to New Branches
  • 500 Years Since the Wedding that Changed the World – Martin Luther and Katharina von Bora
  • Connecting to Martin Luther the Reformer – Exercise Due Diligence
  • Updated Biermann-Lindner and Hartley-Sigmund Family Tree Now Available
  • Lily Biermann (Terrell) Aultman – Lost Lily

Tags

Anna Maria Kessler Anna Marie Kessler Lindner Barlow Beaver County Beerfelden Beermann Biermann Brown Brown County Ohio Byberry Waltons Bützow Cincinnati de la Marche descendants of Martin Luther the Reformer Dierksen DNA Dresden Elsasser Emil Max Heinrich Lindner Gaa Groeschel Hartley Hemesath John Campbell Kessler Lang Lindner Lorup Luther Maier Martin Luther Maune Max Lindner Mecklenburg-Schwerin Miller Philadelphia Pomeroy Ohio Ruwolt Saxony Schatz Schulte Stephan Walton Whipple Wippel

Recent Comments

  • Theodor Hoerl on Charles Solger – Did He Leave One Family to Start Another? – 52 Ancestors #19
  • Patrick wallace on Johann Hans Michel Sigmund – The Ordeal of the Love and Unity – 52 Ancestors #40
  • Cheryl Biermann Hartley on Martin Luther – Yes, THAT Martin Luther – 52 Ancestors #13
  • Merrilee Morrison-Cotter on Martin Luther – Yes, THAT Martin Luther – 52 Ancestors #13
  • Cheryl Biermann Hartley on Johann Hans Michel Sigmund – The Ordeal of the Love and Unity – 52 Ancestors #40

Categories

  • 52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks
  • 52 Ancestors Redux
  • Biermann
  • Brown
  • Hartley
  • Lindner
  • Sigmund
  • Uncategorized

Visitor Stats

Flag Counter

Comment Policy

©2026 My Search for the Past | Powered by Superb Themes